Mon November 14, 2011
South Korean President Faces Mounting Pressures
Originally published on Wed November 16, 2011 7:39 am
A free trade agreement with the U.S. more than four years in the making is causing a big political headache for South Korean President Lee Myung-bak.
On Tuesday, he was scheduled to visit lawmakers in Parliament to try to persuade them to ratify the deal, a step he has never taken before over a single specific issue. Lee is also under pressure in the polls, and facing criticism over his North Korea policy.
But in a wide-ranging exclusive interview with NPR last week, Lee called the disagreement in the National Assembly "part of a protracted political disagreement," and not about the FTA per se. He is also facing hardening opposition on the streets. On Sunday, in the biggest demonstration so far this year, thousands protested against the deal, which they say favors the U.S. and is "unpatriotic."
"The majority of South Koreans are supportive of the [United States-Korea Free Trade Agreement]," Lee said, although he did also address the lingering anti-American sentiment that resurfaces periodically.
"When you talk about a very small minority — a handful of those with anti-American sentiments — they are the most vocal, they tend to get very active, they are the first ones to come out on the streets and voice discontent when something happens," he said.
Nicknamed "The Bulldozer," Lee is South Korea's first conservative president in a decade. But as he nears the last year of his five-year term, he faces declining popularity amid concerns about the trade deal impasse, as well as deteriorating ties with North Korea and a widening wealth gap.
Relationship With North Korea
Since Lee took office, a pattern of escalating provocations culminated in North Korea shelling the South Korean island of Yeonpyeong in November 2010, killing four South Koreans. This followed the sinking in March of the South Korean corvette the Cheonan, with a loss of 46 South Korean servicemen.
Lee had come to office vowing to roll back the earlier "sunshine policy" of engagement, by making aid to Pyongyang conditional on steps toward nuclear disarmament. But he denies this constitutes a hard-line approach to Pyongyang.
"There's this wide perception that somehow our North Korea policy was rather hard-line, but it wasn't," Lee said. "Ever since my first day in office, my North Korea policy has been very flexible."
Recently, Lee has replaced his unification minister, Hyun In-taek, who was seen as a hard-liner, and restarted medical aid to North Korea. The president defends his approach as consistent.
"There is no change, but my North Korea policy did in fact yield substantial results, but these results you cannot see with your eyes right now. But there are fundamental changes as a result of our North Korean policy," he says.
However, observers argue that the policy has resulted in a loss of South Korean leverage over the North.
"The logic of the policy is passivity — that's how it's supposed to work. By disengaging, you will change North Korean behavior," says North Korea expert John Delury of Yonsei University. "So far ... it has changed North Korean behavior — it's made it a bit more aggressive."
Delury argues that this has also damaged South Korea's strategic position.
"In an economic context, there is no question South Korea is losing leverage to China," he says. "The North Korea-China economic relationship is growing significantly. Their diplomatic relationship is stronger than it has been since the Korean War era."
What this means, Delury says, is that South Korea will have to go through Beijing to get things done with North Korea, rather than dealing directly in its relationship with North Korea to achieve its own goals.
Problems At Home
Domestically, Lee was dealt another blow last month, when a vocal critic, civic activist Park Won-soon, won the election for Seoul mayor. The vote was largely seen as a referendum on the president's rule, and the candidate backed by Lee did worse than expected.
By contrast, the new mayor is basically seen as the anti-Lee Myung-bak candidate; he supports reconciliation with North Korea, he opposes the free trade agreement, and he's very popular among young people.
Speaking to NPR at a lunch event, the new Seoul mayor didn't pull his punches.
"Since the inauguration of Mr. Lee Myung-bak, I was very much disappointed with his politics and policies. ... The paradigm he pursued was outdated," Park says. "Not only in economics, but also in many social and political issues, he made many mistakes. ... I made up my mind to run for this position as Seoul mayor to change it."
An Ally In The U.S.
However, one bright spot during Lee's term has been ever closer ties with the United States. During Lee's state visit to Washington last month, President Obama and Lee spent so much time together that The New York Times wrote of a "presidential man-crush." On a personal level, Lee sees many similarities between himself and Obama.
"One thing that I've always noticed about Obama is the fact that he displays a lot of Asian characteristics — both in his temperament and way of thinking," Lee says. "Outwardly he's very calm and collected, but inside he's a man of resolve."
Lee says he thinks that helped the two presidents develop a sense of camaraderie and allowed them to talk on a more personal level about many issues. That, perhaps, is one of the reasons why many people used the terms "bromance" and "best friend" to describe the relationship.
But, while Lee toured the U.S., Obama emphasized his "great confidence" in the South Korean president's leadership, directly linking this to South Korea's approval of the free trade agreement, which has already been ratified by Congress.
That confidence could be undermined if the free trade agreement doesn't get ratified soon. So a protracted political stalemate in South Korea could embarrass Lee, and might even sour the bromance.
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
Of course, Wisconsin's political debate takes place in the context of a tough economy. And it's in that same context that the United States has finally been moving forward with free trade agreements. Given deep skepticism about jobs that might be lost, as well as gained, it took years for Congress to consider ratifying a deal with South Korea. And it turns out, the politics are also challenging on the South Korean side.
Today, South Korea's President Lee Myung-bak visited lawmakers in parliament to try to persuade them to ratify the deal. NPR's Louisa Lim recently met him for an interview in Seoul.
LOUISA LIM, BYLINE: Opposition to the Free Trade agreement with the U.S. is hardening, both on the streets of Seoul and inside parliament. This weekend, thousands protested that the deal favors the U.S. and is unpatriotic.
Talking to NPR last week, President Lee Myung-bak called the disagreements in the National Assembly part of a long-running political dispute and not about the FTA per se. He claims the majority of South Koreans support the deal.
PRESIDENT LEE MYUNG-BAK: (Through Translator) When you talk about a very small minority or a handful of those with anti-American sentiments, they are the most vocal. They tend to get very active. They are the first ones to come out on the streets and to voice their discontent whenever something happens. And they are very good at utilizing those opportunities.
LIM: Lee is nicknamed the Bulldozer. He's South Korea's first Conservative president in a decade. But as he nears the last year of his five-year term, he faces declining popularity amid concerns about deteriorating ties with North Korea and a widening wealth gap.
(SOUNDBITE OF A NEWSCLIP)
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Houses were burning on a South Korean island under fire from the North Korean artillery...
LIM: Last year, in a pattern of escalating provocations, North Korea attacked the South Korean island of Yeonpyeong. This, after North Korean fury at Lee's decision to roll back the earlier Sunshine Policy of engagement. Recently, Lee has replaced his unification minister and restarted medical aid to North Korea. But he denies he's changed track.
MYUNG-BAK: (Through Translator) There is no change. And I must also add that my North Korea policy, in fact, did yield substantial results. But these results you cannot see with your own eyes right now, but there are fundamental changes as a result our North Korean policy.
LIM: Others argue the policy has resulted in a loss of South Korean leverage over the North. Here's North Korea expert John Delury from Yonsei University.
JOHN DELURY: The logic of the policy is passivity. By disengaging you will change North Korea behavior. That's the logic. So far, by disengaging it has changed North Korea behavior. It's made it a bit more aggressive.
LIM: Lee was dealt another blow last month; a vocal critic, civic activist Park Won-soon, won the election for Seoul mayor. The new mayor is basically seen as the anti-Lee Myung-bak candidate. He supports reconciliation with North Korea, he opposes the Free Trade Agreement, and he's very popular among young people.
Speaking to NPR at a lunch event, the new Seoul mayor, Park Won-soon, didn't pull his punches.
MAYOR PARK WON-SOON: Since the inauguration of Mr. Lee Myung-bak, I was very much disappointed with his politics and policies. Not only in economics, but also in many social and political issues, he made many mistakes.
(SOUNDBITE OF A CROWD)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Ladies and gentlemen, the National Anthem of the Republic of Korea.
(SOUNDBITE OF NATIONAL ANTHEM OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOREA)
LIM: However, one bright spot during Lee's term has been ever closer ties with the U.S. During Lee's State visit to the U.S. last month, he spent so much time with President Obama that the New York Times wrote of a presidential man-crush. Lee sees their similarities.
MYUNG-BAK: (Through Translator) One thing that I've always noticed about President Obama is the fact that he displays a lot of Asian characteristics, both in his temperament and his way of thinking. Outwardly, he may appear very calm and collected, but inside we know that he's a man of resolve. And so, I think that helped us develop a sense of camaraderie. And we're able to talk on a more personal level about many issues. And so, I think that's perhaps one of the reasons why many people have pointed out and even used the word bromance...
(SOUNDBITE OF LAUGHTER)
MYUNG-BAK: ...and best friend and so forth.
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: I have great confidence in his leadership...
LIM: But Mr. Obama's confidence could be undermined if South Korea doesn't approve the Free Trade Agreement soon. It's already been ratified by the U.S. Congress. So a protracted political stalemate in South Korea could embarrass Lee, and might even sour the bromance.
Louisa Lim NPR News.
INSKEEP: It's MORNING EDITION from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.