A life-without-parole sentence for a man convicted of raping an elderly Nowata County woman has been thrown out by an Oklahoma appeals court that cited "alarming" prosecutorial misconduct during closing arguments.
The Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals on Wednesday vacated the sentences of Travis Dillion Barnes for first-degree rape and burglary. The court said the prosecutor's commentary on Barnes' right to a trial was "nothing short of alarming."
The right of a criminal defendant to a jury trial is protected by both the Oklahoma and U.S. constitutions, and the court said a defendant cannot be punished for exercising that right.
Nowata County District Attorney Kevin Buchanan said his former top prosecutor, Jared Sigler, may have gone too far in his argument, but that it was an emotionally charged case.