Latest Information:
U.S.
10:30 am
Mon April 2, 2012

N.H. Parents On Their Own In Abuse, Neglect Cases

Originally published on Mon April 2, 2012 4:12 pm

In most places in the U.S., if a parent is charged with abuse or neglect of a child and can't afford a lawyer, he's appointed one. That lawyer's job is to defend the parent and reunite the family if possible.

But faced with a budget shortfall, New Hampshire has taken the unusual step of eliminating that funding.

The court and state officials charged with enforcing the new policy now worry that the lack of representation is hurting parents and their children — and children's advocates are concerned that other states may eventually follow New Hampshire's lead.

Only Two States

In a recent preliminary hearing in the Rochester Family Division Courthouse, Judge Susan Ashley took extra time to ensure that a father without a lawyer understood the proceedings.

The man is being charged with neglect because he doesn't have anywhere for his daughter to live right now.

"One of the topics that we are going to go through today is making sure you have an understanding of what the potential consequences of this type of case are to your parental rights and responsibilities," she tells the man, whose name has been withheld because the case is sealed.

"If the court made a decision that your parental rights should be terminated, it would be at that point [that] you would no longer have any legal rights, duties or obligations," she says. "Do you understand that's a potential consequence to this type of a case?"

The man says he understands that he could lose his 4-year-old daughter forever, but he also has no idea what he needs to do to get the girl back.

"It's all happening ... pretty quick," he says. "And [I'm] having a hard time kind of processing everything that's going on, and knowing what's going" to happen next, he says.

For the first time in 30 years, New Hampshire isn't offering parents any legal representation in these types of cases. Funding was eliminated in the most recent round of budget cuts.

That makes New Hampshire and Mississippi the only two states that don't provide lawyers to indigent parents in abuse and neglect proceedings.

'Fish In A Barrel'

After nine months and hundreds of these cases, New Hampshire state officials say the vast majority of parents don't have lawyers — and many aren't fit to defend themselves.

The 34-year old father at Ashley's hearing is an example of that. He dropped out of school after the 10th grade, he says, and his dyslexia makes reading and writing difficult.

Parents who are unable to adequately defend themselves make state attorney Peter Brunette's job — arguing against the parents — easier. But he doesn't feel good about it.

"It's like shooting fish in a barrel sometimes. And it's not fun," Brunette says. "Without a lawyer, there's no way they can navigate this system in a way that ensures that their rights are being adequately protected. That's the problem we are all struggling with right now."

In New Hampshire, parents have about 12 months to shape up and address the source of the neglect. Sometimes that means getting out of a violent relationship or receiving counseling for substance abuse or mental illness.

But when you add in navigating a complicated legal world, Ashley worries it's just too much for many parents.

"Suddenly those 12 months have slipped away," she says. "And we find ourselves at a permanency hearing where the parent hasn't done what they needed to do to correct the conditions of neglect."

Ultimately, Ashley worries that many parents are incapable of sharing relevant information, making it that much harder for the court to get it right.

Vivek Sankaran, a professor of law at the University of Michigan, predicts New Hampshire may get exactly what it has historically tried to avoid — a generation of kids who grow up without their parents.

The practice of child welfare has become "much more sophisticated" in recent years, Sankaran says. "And then you get [these cuts], where we've just reverted back to where we were in the 1960s or the 1950s."

Other States May Follow Suit

The question of whether parents have a constitutional right to an attorney has now made its way to the state Supreme Court.

Sankaran says child advocacy experts around the country are watching the New Hampshire case closely. Sankaran fears other states may follow New Hampshire's lead if the court rules with the state.

But the father of the 4-year-old girl in Rochester is not thinking about policy implications. Frustrated, he says he just sees an indifferent system beating on him.

"I think people just look at people that are losing their kids — people just look at them like they are scumbags," the man says. "I don't think people understand it ain't always due to abuse or anything like that. Sometimes it's over financial problems, why they need help."

The father says social workers tell him they want to work with him to get him and his daughter back together.

He doesn't think she'll end up adopted, but without a lawyer, he says it's possible that's how his case could turn out.

Copyright 2013 New Hampshire Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.nhpr.org/.

Transcript

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

In New Hampshire, if you're charged with abuse or neglect of a child, you can no longer count on the state to provide you with a lawyer. Most states provide a defense for those who can't afford one.

And as New Hampshire Public Radio's Dan Gorenstein reports, some officials worry that parents and their children are suffering because of the new policy.

DAN GORENSTEIN, BYLINE: Lately, lots of abuse and neglect cases in New Hampshire start out something like this.

JUDGE SUSAN ASHLEY: One of the topics that we are going to go through today is making sure that you have a clear understanding of what the potential consequences of this type of case are...

GORENSTEIN: We're in a preliminary hearing with Judge Susan Ashley. The case is sealed, so we aren't using family names. Since the father doesn't have a lawyer, Judge Ashley is taking extra time to be sure he understands what's happening.

ASHLEY: Ultimately, if the court made a decision that your parental rights should be terminated, it would be at that point that you would no longer have any legal rights, duties or obligations. Do you understand that that's a potential consequence to this type of a case?

GORENSTEIN: The man understands that he could lose his four-year-old forever. He's being charged with neglect because he doesn't have anywhere for her to live right now. But what he needs to do to get the girl back, he's got no clue.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: It's kind of all happening really quick. And, you know, I - having a hard time kind of processing everything that's going on.

GORENSTEIN: For the first time in 30 years, the state isn't offering parents any legal representation. New Hampshire has now joined Mississippi as the only other state that doesn't provide lawyers in abuse and neglect proceedings. After nine months and hundreds of these cases, state officials say the vast majority of parents don't have lawyers. And many aren't fit to defend themselves. The 34-year-old father is an example of that.

and what's the highest level of education you have?

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Tenth grade. Yeah, I have dyslexia. I have a hard time reading and writing.

GORENSTEIN: The man's fiancee points to an emergency exit sign. He can't read it, which all makes lawyer Peter Brunette's job easier, kind of.

PETER BRUNETTE: It's like shooting fish in a barrel sometimes. And it's not fun.

GORENSTEIN: Brunette is an attorney for the state. His job is to argue against the parents.

BRUNETTE: Without a lawyer, there's no way they can navigate this system in a way that ensures that their rights are being adequately protected. And that's the problem, I think, that we're all struggling with right now.

GORENSTEIN: In New Hampshire, parents have about 12 months to shape up and address the source of the neglect. Sometimes that's counseling for substance abuse or mental illness, or getting out of a violent relationship. But when you add navigating a complicated legal world to that, Judge Susan Ashley worries it's too much for lots of parents.

ASHLEY: Suddenly those 12 months have slipped away. And we find ourselves at a permanency hearing where the parent hasn't done what they needed to do to correct the conditions of neglect.

GORENSTEIN: Ultimately, Ashley worries too many parents are incapable of sharing relevant information, making it that much harder for the court to get it right.

University of Michigan law professor Vivek Sankaran predicts New Hampshire may get exactly what it's historically tried to avoid - a generation of kids who grow up without their parents.

VIVEK SANKARAN: What makes what happened in New Hampshire so striking, the practice of child welfare has become much more sophisticated. And then you get this, where we've just reverted back to where we were in the 1960s or 1950s.

GORENSTEIN: The question of whether parents have a constitutional right to an attorney has made its way to the state Supreme Court. Sankaran says child advocates around the country are watching closely. He fears others may follow New Hampshire's lead, if the court rules with the state.

The 34-year old father, he's not thinking about policy implications.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: I think people just look at people that are losing their kids or, you know, I think people just look at them like: Oh, they're scumbags. They're not. I don't think people understand it ain't always due to abuse or anything like that. Sometimes it's over financial problems of why they need help.

GORENSTEIN: The father says social workers say they want to work with him, get him and his daughter back together. He doesn't think she'll end up adopted, but without a lawyer he guesses it's possible.

For NPR News, I'm Dan Gorenstein in Concord, New Hampshire. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.